Why Your Streams Aren't Earning Royalties (and How to Fix It)
Why your streams aren't earning royalties: Spotify's 1,000-stream rule, artificial streams, missing codes or metadata, unregistered publishing and splits never set.
Stillmore Group5 min read
When streams don't turn into royalties, the cause is usually one of six things: the track is under Spotify's threshold of 1,000 streams in the previous 12 months, the streams were flagged as artificial, the money hasn't arrived yet, a code or piece of metadata is missing, your publishing isn't registered, or splits were never set, so the money went to someone else. Most of these can be fixed from now on.
Work through them in order.
1. The track is under Spotify's threshold
Since April 2024, a track on Spotify has to reach at least 1,000 streams in the previous 12 months, and a minimum number of unique listeners, before it earns recording royalties. Spotify doesn't publish the listener number (Spotify). The rule was announced in November 2023 and went live on April 1, 2024 (Spotify for Artists).
What that means in practice:
- It's counted per track. One song on an EP can qualify while another doesn't.
- It applies to recording royalties only. Publishing royalties aren't affected.
- The money stays in the royalty pool: Spotify says it goes to increase payments to the tracks that are eligible, and that 99.5% of all streams are of tracks that reach the threshold (Spotify's royalties guide).
- You can estimate where a track stands with the Last 12 months filter on the Music page of Spotify for Artists. Spotify says that's only an estimate; the royalty reports from your label or distributor are the source of truth.
What to do: Very small tracks won't earn recording royalties on Spotify. Put your promotion behind the songs you most want heard, instead of spreading attention thinly across the whole catalog.
2. The streams were flagged as artificial
Spotify defines an artificial stream as one that doesn't reflect genuine listening, such as plays from bots or scripts. Detected artificial streams earn no royalties and don't count in public numbers or charts. In serious cases a track can be removed from playlists or taken down, and since April 2024 Spotify has charged labels and distributors per track when it finds flagrant artificial streaming on their content (Spotify on artificial streaming). Distributors may follow up with warnings, penalty fees, account suspensions or removals.
You don't have to have bought fake streams yourself. A paid playlist placement or a promotion service can be the source. Spotify warns against any service that promises streams or playlist spots in return for money.
What to do: Look in Spotify for Artists for sudden spikes that fall away, listeners in places you can't explain and unusual sources of streams. Tell your distributor about anything odd and about any promotion you've paid for, and stop using services that guarantee results.
3. The money hasn't arrived yet
Royalties always arrive months after the streams. Stores calculate each month after it closes, report to distributors after that, and your distributor can only pay once those reports come in. Streams you see in Spotify for Artists this week won't be on this month's statement. More in how streaming royalties work.
What to do: Check which usage period your latest statement covers before deciding something's wrong.
4. A code or a piece of metadata is missing or wrong
- ISRCs. Each recording needs its own ISRC, and the same recording should keep it everywhere. If a track is delivered again under a new code, it starts a new history, and earnings can be split across two lines or matched to the wrong version. See ISRC and UPC codes explained.
- Registrations for broadcast and public performance. Recordings also earn when they're played on the radio or in public, collected by neighboring rights organizations. In the UK, PPL needs each recording's ISRC and a full performer line-up; if the data is incomplete, the recording is marked invalid and the rights holder's royalties are withheld until it's complete (PPL).
- Names that don't match. Different spellings of an artist or writer name across releases and registrations make matching harder everywhere. The usual culprits are in metadata mistakes that get releases rejected.
What to do: Run a free check of your catalog to see what stores and distributors would flag, including missing UPCs and ISRCs, and fix what it finds with your distributor.
5. Your publishing isn't registered
Every stream also earns money for the song itself, the composition, and your distributor doesn't collect it. Spotify pays publishing royalties to publishers, collecting societies and mechanical agencies, based on where the listening happened (Spotify). If nobody registered your song, that money can't find you.
- Performance royalties. Join a performing rights organization (PRS for Music in the UK, ASCAP or BMI in the US, and so on) and register every song. PRS says registering is what lets it track where your work is used and pay you (PRS for Music).
- Mechanical royalties. In the US, The MLC pays digital mechanical royalties to its members, so songwriters who handle their own publishing have to join and register their works to collect (The MLC). Royalties The MLC can't match, or that nobody has claimed, from use since January 1, 2021, are held for at least three years and then distributed to publishers and self-administered songwriters by market share (The MLC FAQ).
What to do: Register as a songwriter, register every song with the agreed splits, and check that your co-writers have registered theirs.
6. Splits were never set
If splits weren't set up where the money is collected, everything goes to the account that delivered the release. The producer or featured artist who expected a share gets nothing, and fixing it later means money changing hands between people after the fact. On the songwriting side, co-writers who register shares that don't agree end up in a dispute that has to be resolved.
What to do: Agree splits in writing before release, set the recording splits per track wherever the money is collected, and register matching songwriting splits with every society.
A quick diagnosis
- Fewer than 1,000 streams on Spotify in the last 12 months? That track doesn't earn recording royalties there yet.
- Sudden spikes from sources you can't explain? Talk to your distributor about artificial streaming.
- Recent streams? Check the period your statement covers.
- Missing codes or details? Check your catalog and fix them with your distributor.
- Wrote the song? Check your society and mechanical registrations.
- Worked with other people? Check the splits.
Key takeaways
- On Spotify, a track needs 1,000 streams in 12 months, plus enough unique listeners, to earn recording royalties.
- Artificial streams earn nothing and can cost fees or the release itself.
- Royalties arrive months after the streams.
- Correct codes, registered songs and agreed splits are what connect streams to money.
How Stillmore Group helps
A person at Stillmore Group reviews every release before it's delivered, so missing codes and metadata problems can be caught before the stores see them. Statements show earnings by release, store and country, and royalty splits are set per track, so everyone's share is part of the setup from the start. To run your own numbers, try the free royalty calculator.
- why am i not getting royalties from spotify
- spotify 1000 streams rule
- streams but no royalties
- spotify minimum streams to get paid
- unclaimed songwriting royalties
- artificial streams spotify